Rate case · ☀️ Sunlight Governance
Rocky Mountain Power general rate case, Utah PSC Docket No. 24-035-04
The record in three steps
-
Step 1
What the utility asked for
On June 28, 2024, Rocky Mountain Power filed its application for a general rate increase, with an original request of $667.3 million.
Rocky Mountain Power’s Application for General Rate Increase (PDF) -
Step 2
What the commission ordered
On April 25, 2025, the Public Service Commission of Utah approved an increase of $87.2 million.
Order, Docket Nos. 24-035-04, 23-035-40 and 23-035-44 (PDF) -
Step 3
What stayed confidential
The public order names five parts of the record that are designated confidential or redacted, listed below.
The public order, pp. 59, 88, 89, 103 and 147 (PDF)
What the order decided
Every figure in the order’s decision
- Original request
- $667.3 million
- Amended application
- $393.7 million
- Final revised request
- $330.2 million
- Approved increase
- $87.2 million (26.4% of the final revised request)
- Deferred to a future Energy Balancing Account filing
- up to $240.1 million
- Return on equity
- 9.65% requested; 9.375% approved
- Average single-family residential bill (700 kWh)
- +$4.31 a month (4.7%) in 2025
What is confidential or redacted
The public order does not state what share of the filing is confidential. It does name specific parts of the record that are designated confidential or redacted, listed below. Testimony in the docket is posted in redacted public versions.
- The price of the wind contractsWind contract pricing.
“Because the pricing of the PPAs and the costs associated with the other Wind Projects are designated confidential, the PSC discusses these issues in general terms.” p. 103
- The size of each proposed overhaul-cost correctionGeneration overhaul adjustments.
“They argue that RMP should remove the converted units from its four-year calculation, each recommending a confidential adjustment to correct the issue.” p. 89
- Where the injury and damage claims came fromInjuries and damages claims data.
“DPU acknowledges RMP provided data on the origin of claims but notes the information is heavily redacted, precluding reasonable evaluation.” p. 88
- The inputs to the load forecastLoad forecast model variables.
“much information is designated confidential in GRCs and RMP may avail itself of existing processes to protect any confidential information.” p. 59
- An insurer’s report on its underwritingInsurer underwriting exhibit.
“RMP also provided a confidential exhibit it requested one of its insurers to prepare, which discusses the insurer’s underwriting process” p. 147
The public version vs. full visibility
The left column is what anyone can read in the posted order. The right column names what the confidential version holds, as the order describes it. No withheld value is guessed.
| Record | Public version | Full visibility would show |
|---|---|---|
| Cedar Springs IV wind power purchase agreement (350.4 MW) | Pricing designated confidential. The order says DPU noted a “significant increase in price” from the 2020 bid, but discusses it only “in general terms.” ██████ | The contract price and how much it rose from the 2020 All-Source RFP bid. |
| Generation overhaul expense adjustment | OCS, UAE and DPU each proposed a correction; the amounts are confidential. ██████ | Each party’s proposed dollar adjustment. |
| Injuries and damages claims data | DPU describes the claims-origin data it received as “heavily redacted.” ██████ | Where the claims behind the test-year expense came from. |
| Insurer underwriting exhibit | A confidential exhibit. The order says its threshold for a significant verdict is “a small fraction” of the utility’s liability in the James wildfire case. ██████ | The insurer’s stated threshold and underwriting factors. |
What the Office of Consumer Services argued
The Office of Consumer Services (OCS), which represents residential and small business customers before the PSC, was a party to the case.
- Recommended a 9.375% return on equity, below the 9.65% Rocky Mountain Power requested. The PSC adopted 9.375%, finding the OCS recommendation reasonable under the principle of gradualism. p. 21
- Asked the PSC to disallow at least $15,289,781 of claimed wildfire-related deferred costs: $5,681,724 in labor costs OCS argued were already recovered through base rates, and $9,608,057 spent under a 2023 wildfire plan the PSC had not approved. p. 131
- Joined other parties in opposing full recovery of projected excess liability insurance premiums, arguing the utility had not provided substantial evidence that the full amount was prudent. p. 148
- Argued the allocation factor used to spread those insurance premiums across states “does not assign the costs to the jurisdictions in proportion to the amount each jurisdiction contributes to the increase,” violating cost-causation principles. p. 158
- Recommended removing two Jim Bridger units converted to natural gas, and Craig Unit 2, from the generation overhaul expense average; the amount of its adjustment is confidential. p. 89
Filed vs. Ordered
The utility’s main public request and the PSC’s order in this docket, the record behind the ask “Publish one confidential contract.” Each line is the public document’s title and date.
| Step | Date | Public document |
|---|---|---|
| Filed by Rocky Mountain Power | Rocky Mountain Power’s Application for General Rate Increase | |
| Ordered by the PSC | Order, Docket Nos. 24-035-04, 23-035-40 and 23-035-44 |
Public filings since the order
No new public PSC filings flagged since the April 25, 2025 order.
Related legislator votes on PolitiDex
These Utah bills changed how the PSC evaluates utility resource decisions. PolitiDex does not yet have a Utah bill on PSC confidentiality or disclosure.
- S.B. 224 (2024), Energy Independence Amendments, enacted. Changes the factors the PSC weighs in evaluating energy resource decisions and sets terms for cost recovery. House 54-19-2 · Senate 21-6-2
- H.B. 201 (2025), Energy Resource Amendments, enacted. Changes how the PSC evaluates integrated resource plans. House 57-10-8 · Senate 21-6-2
Take one step
The ask: Publish one confidential contract.
Ask Rocky Mountain Power to file a public version of one confidential contract in this docket: the pricing terms of the Cedar Springs IV wind power purchase agreement. The utility holds the contract, so the burden of showing why any term must stay confidential rests with the utility. This is a request about one existing document. It does not ask for any new law.